I have been a serial Lotus owner... having had the pleasure of owning almost every version on Elise/Exige over the past 20 years!
Stepped 'UP' into a MY14 N/A Evora Sports Racer a few months ago... my BEST Lotus ever! Amazing drive, quiet (or loud!), quick, comfortable, DNA Lotus handling, great looks, super classy interior (IMHO, better than the 400/410/430), the perfect Lotus actually.
Despite subsequent drives of those 'faster' machines, I do agree that the last S1's were indeed the best!
Good luck with your search :>) Your budget will get you a great car!